• About Us
  • Get Insights to Your Inbox
Saturday, May 31, 2025
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in Author
Search Events
Filter by Categories
Action Learning
Artificial Intelligence in Business
Book Club
Books
BU Today
Business Challenges
Business Education
Business Functions
Business Policy & Markets
Corporate Strategy
Digital Business
Digital Business Institute
Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
Entrepreneurship & Innovation
Events
Expert Take
Feature
Finance & Accounting
Future of Business Education
Future of Work
Global Media
Harvard Business Review
Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech
Human Resources Policy Institute
Innovation
Insights Live
Institute for Sustainable Energy
Journals
Language of Business
Leadership & Management
Local Media
Marketing
Media Mention
Multimedia
National Media
Newsletter Spotlight
Op-Ed
Operations
Opinion
Our Insights
Partners in Business Ethics
Podcast
Publications
Research Institutes
Risk
ScienceDirect
Silicon Valley Bank
Sloan Management Review
Social Impact
Special Series
Susilo Institute for Ethics in the Global Economy
Technology
The Brink
Thinkers50@BUQuestrom: Passion & Purpose
Videos
Insights@Questrom
  • Our Insights
    • All
    • Business Challenges
    • Business Education
    • Business Functions
    Boston dockworkers among thousands on strike nationwide 

    High tariffs, immigration crackdown, funding cuts: BU professor warns of ‘Trump Trifecta’ 

    Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Rep. Madeleine Dean demand food and beverage CEOs put a stop to ‘shrinkflation’ 

    Mass. leaders worried for seniors and kids as Trump agenda bill clears House 

    What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

    Stop Making Cents: US Mint Moves Forward With Plans to Kill the Penny 

    How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

    How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Could the GPT Store Turn ChatGPT into a Platform Powerhouse? 

    The Right Amount of Cards, Cash and ID to Carry in Your Wallet

    The ‘Best and Final’ Job Offer Usually Isn’t Final. How You Can Negotiate 

    From Hollywood to the Hardware Store: The Real-World Impact of a 100% Tariff 

    From Hollywood to the Hardware Store: The Real-World Impact of a 100% Tariff 

    Bank Failures Show Us What Not to Do with Our Own Finances

    Bank Failures Show Us What Not to Do with Our Own Finances

  • Videos & Podcast
    • All
    • Podcast
    • Videos
    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Tariffs and Their Economic Impact

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Navigating Internet Privacy: Unpacking Cookies, Dark Patterns, and Future Data Protection Challenges (2)

    Beyond Prototypes: Rethinking Innovation in Complex Ecosystems with Prof. Douglas Hannah

    Beyond Prototypes: Rethinking Innovation in Complex Ecosystems with Prof. Douglas Hannah

    Is Business Broken? Season 2 out now! 

    Is Business Broken? Season 2 out now! 

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Redefining Retirement: Navigating Emotional and Social Transitions with Insightful Strategies

    Life After Cookies: Who Uses Google’s Privacy Sandbox? – Garrett Johnson

    Life After Cookies: Who Uses Google’s Privacy Sandbox? – Garrett Johnson

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Real Estate Ripples from a Landmark Settlement

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    The Hidden Wisdom of Cultural Pushback

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Fusion Strategy: Navigating the Industrial Evolution

  • Insights Events
    • Events
    • Insights Live
    • Questrom Institute Events
  • In the Media
    • All
    • BU Today
    • Global Media
    • Local Media
    • National Media
    • Op-Ed
    • The Brink
    Boston dockworkers among thousands on strike nationwide 

    High tariffs, immigration crackdown, funding cuts: BU professor warns of ‘Trump Trifecta’ 

    Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Rep. Madeleine Dean demand food and beverage CEOs put a stop to ‘shrinkflation’ 

    Mass. leaders worried for seniors and kids as Trump agenda bill clears House 

    What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

    Stop Making Cents: US Mint Moves Forward With Plans to Kill the Penny 

    How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

    How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Could the GPT Store Turn ChatGPT into a Platform Powerhouse? 

    The Right Amount of Cards, Cash and ID to Carry in Your Wallet

    The ‘Best and Final’ Job Offer Usually Isn’t Final. How You Can Negotiate 

    Bank Failures Show Us What Not to Do with Our Own Finances

    Bank Failures Show Us What Not to Do with Our Own Finances

    In a ‘work-from-anywhere’ world, where are people working?

    79,000 lost jobs. $13 billion in GDP gone. Study tallies potential hit to Mass. from Trump’s ‘economic attack.’

    The Hidden Risk of Getting Paid in Stock Options 

    Trump Administration Cancels Scores of Grants to Study Online Misinformation 

  • Publications
    • All
    • Books
    • Harvard Business Review
    • Journals
    • Sloan Management Review
    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Could the GPT Store Turn ChatGPT into a Platform Powerhouse? 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    How to Monetize Volunteer-Driven Platforms 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Leading Global Teams Effectively 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Research: When Prototypes Don’t Yield Useful Insights 

    Transforming Products into Platforms: Unearthing New Avenues for Business Innovation

    Transforming Products into Platforms: Unearthing New Avenues for Business Innovation

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    We’re Still Lonely at Work

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    17 Team-Building Activities for In-Person, Remote, and Hybrid Teams

    3 Ways to Support Employees with Bipolar Disorder

    3 Ways to Support Employees with Bipolar Disorder

    Will That Marketplace Succeed?

    Will That Marketplace Succeed?

  • Questrom Book Club
Insights@Questrom
  • Our Insights
    • All
    • Business Challenges
    • Business Education
    • Business Functions
    Boston dockworkers among thousands on strike nationwide 

    High tariffs, immigration crackdown, funding cuts: BU professor warns of ‘Trump Trifecta’ 

    Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Rep. Madeleine Dean demand food and beverage CEOs put a stop to ‘shrinkflation’ 

    Mass. leaders worried for seniors and kids as Trump agenda bill clears House 

    What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

    Stop Making Cents: US Mint Moves Forward With Plans to Kill the Penny 

    How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

    How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Could the GPT Store Turn ChatGPT into a Platform Powerhouse? 

    The Right Amount of Cards, Cash and ID to Carry in Your Wallet

    The ‘Best and Final’ Job Offer Usually Isn’t Final. How You Can Negotiate 

    From Hollywood to the Hardware Store: The Real-World Impact of a 100% Tariff 

    From Hollywood to the Hardware Store: The Real-World Impact of a 100% Tariff 

    Bank Failures Show Us What Not to Do with Our Own Finances

    Bank Failures Show Us What Not to Do with Our Own Finances

  • Videos & Podcast
    • All
    • Podcast
    • Videos
    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Tariffs and Their Economic Impact

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Navigating Internet Privacy: Unpacking Cookies, Dark Patterns, and Future Data Protection Challenges (2)

    Beyond Prototypes: Rethinking Innovation in Complex Ecosystems with Prof. Douglas Hannah

    Beyond Prototypes: Rethinking Innovation in Complex Ecosystems with Prof. Douglas Hannah

    Is Business Broken? Season 2 out now! 

    Is Business Broken? Season 2 out now! 

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Redefining Retirement: Navigating Emotional and Social Transitions with Insightful Strategies

    Life After Cookies: Who Uses Google’s Privacy Sandbox? – Garrett Johnson

    Life After Cookies: Who Uses Google’s Privacy Sandbox? – Garrett Johnson

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Real Estate Ripples from a Landmark Settlement

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    The Hidden Wisdom of Cultural Pushback

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Fusion Strategy: Navigating the Industrial Evolution

  • Insights Events
    • Events
    • Insights Live
    • Questrom Institute Events
  • In the Media
    • All
    • BU Today
    • Global Media
    • Local Media
    • National Media
    • Op-Ed
    • The Brink
    Boston dockworkers among thousands on strike nationwide 

    High tariffs, immigration crackdown, funding cuts: BU professor warns of ‘Trump Trifecta’ 

    Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Rep. Madeleine Dean demand food and beverage CEOs put a stop to ‘shrinkflation’ 

    Mass. leaders worried for seniors and kids as Trump agenda bill clears House 

    What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

    Stop Making Cents: US Mint Moves Forward With Plans to Kill the Penny 

    How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

    How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Could the GPT Store Turn ChatGPT into a Platform Powerhouse? 

    The Right Amount of Cards, Cash and ID to Carry in Your Wallet

    The ‘Best and Final’ Job Offer Usually Isn’t Final. How You Can Negotiate 

    Bank Failures Show Us What Not to Do with Our Own Finances

    Bank Failures Show Us What Not to Do with Our Own Finances

    In a ‘work-from-anywhere’ world, where are people working?

    79,000 lost jobs. $13 billion in GDP gone. Study tallies potential hit to Mass. from Trump’s ‘economic attack.’

    The Hidden Risk of Getting Paid in Stock Options 

    Trump Administration Cancels Scores of Grants to Study Online Misinformation 

  • Publications
    • All
    • Books
    • Harvard Business Review
    • Journals
    • Sloan Management Review
    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Could the GPT Store Turn ChatGPT into a Platform Powerhouse? 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    How to Monetize Volunteer-Driven Platforms 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Leading Global Teams Effectively 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Research: When Prototypes Don’t Yield Useful Insights 

    Transforming Products into Platforms: Unearthing New Avenues for Business Innovation

    Transforming Products into Platforms: Unearthing New Avenues for Business Innovation

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    We’re Still Lonely at Work

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    17 Team-Building Activities for In-Person, Remote, and Hybrid Teams

    3 Ways to Support Employees with Bipolar Disorder

    3 Ways to Support Employees with Bipolar Disorder

    Will That Marketplace Succeed?

    Will That Marketplace Succeed?

  • Questrom Book Club
Insights@Questrom
Home Our Insights Business Challenges Business Policy & Markets

What today’s labor leaders can learn from the explosive rise and quick fall of the typesetters union

Jay ZagorskybyJay Zagorsky
October 5, 2023
in Business Policy & Markets, Media Mention
31
0
What today’s labor leaders can learn from the explosive rise and quick fall of the typesetters union
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Can a seemingly robust labor union simply collapse? The news is full of stories about growing union power – but just because a union is strong now doesn’t mean it’ll stay that way. Important unions have put themselves out of business before. The International Typographical Union, or ITU, is one such example. Once it was among the nation’s most significant unions, but it disappeared in just a few decades.

I am a business school professor who is fascinated by the lessons of the ITU – first, because I teach courses about unions, and second, because I inadvertently participated in the ITU’s demise. But more on that later.

More than just a ‘hot labor summer’

Right now, union leaders are feeling powerful.

More than 360,000 workers have gone on strike in 2023 – nearly three times as many as in all of 2022. The United Auto Workers union is currently striking against Detroit’s Big Three and demanding a 36% pay hike. UPS recently agreed to union demands for a generous new contract, under which the most senior drivers will eventually earn about $170,000 a year. Hollywood was shut down by the screenwriters’ and actors’ strikes.

However, union leaders would be wise not to overplay their hands. The typesetters guild boasted more than 100,000 members at its peak. Today it serves as a cautionary example of how quickly union power can erode.

A brief digression: What is typesetting, anyway?

Our story begins in the 1500s with the invention of the movable-type printing press. Workers called typesetters would take individual blocks of letters and arrange them into lines of text. They would store unused letters in two cases: capital letters in an upper case and smaller letters in the easier-to-access lower case. That practice – which is why English speakers still describe letters as “uppercase” and “lowercase” – would be ripe for disruption a few centuries later.

A typesetter’s biggest concern was letters falling out when put on the printing press. To prevent this, all lines were made justified, or the same width, so text could be locked into a rectangular frame. Being a good typesetter demanded physical skills to move blocks of type quickly. It also took intellect, since typesetters acted as de facto proofreaders and layout designers.

An early American union

Fast-forward a few hundred years. U.S. labor unions started picking up steam after the Civil War, and typographers were quick to unionize, since their high literacy levels helped with organizing. They formed the International Typographical Union in 1852 with more than 1,000 members.

Thirty years after its founding, the ITU faced a major technological shock. In 1886, the inventor Ottmar Mergenthaler was granted a patent for the Linotype machine. This machine allowed operators to select characters by typing them on a keyboard instead of picking them from a type case.

The Linotype’s advantages were quickly evident. A skilled operator could set 6,000 characters per hour, many times faster than a hand compositor. The Linotype also didn’t require blocks of letters to be re-sorted into type cases after material was printed. Instead, lines of type could be melted down and reused.

A black-and-white photo shows a row of Linotype machines -- large, intimidating-looking metal contraptions -- towering over the workers using them.
A row of Linotype operators at work in a newspaper office in Atlanta in the 1950s. Lawrence Thornton/Getty Images

The Linotype and competing machines didn’t hurt the union because it made publishing cheaper, which resulted in a burst of printing. In fact, ITU membership increased as new newspapers, magazines and book publishers sprang up, all of whom needed skilled workers who could take handwritten copy and transform it into printed text.

By the start of World War I, ITU membership was over 60,000.

The union’s membership peaked in the 1960s, with newspapers being the biggest employers of ITU members. Newspaper publishers didn’t like the ITU because it meant they had to pay for two different expensive workforces: the reporters who created the content and the typesetters who made that content readable. While only some of the reporters were unionized, almost all of the typesetters were.

The decline of the ITU

Starting in the 1960s, other new developments like phototypesetting and then word processing threatened typesetters’ jobs.

The ITU fought against technological changes with a massive strike in New York City. When the strike started, New York City had seven daily newspapers. After a 114-day shutdown, only three remained: The New York Times, the New York Post and the Daily News.

Dozens of protesters with the ITU stand densely packed together on a New York City street, waving signs and placards.
Members of the International Typographical Union demonstrate outside the offices of The New York Times on Jan. 15, 1963. Bettmann/Getty Images

The relatively high pay of typesetters, combined with their ability to shut down production for long periods of time, made newspapers, magazines and other publishers eager customers for high-tech companies that built computers that automatically determined line breaks, hyphenation and text justification. These computers also saved time by eliminating the need for typing copy twice: first by the author and then by a typesetter.

This second technological revolution devastated ITU membership. From 1984 to 1987, its membership halved. In 1986, it merged with the Communications Workers of America, which today doesn’t even mention typographers on its list of sectors.

Walking the negotiating tightrope

Similarly today, unions are pushing for large wage increases at a time when new technologies pose a threat to those workers’ livelihoods. Autonomous vehicles threaten Teamsters truckers; robots and simpler-to-build electric vehicles threaten United Auto Workers; ChatGPT threatens screenwriters.

Labor leaders walk a fine line: Their job is to advocate for workers, but making aggressive demands can backfire if they prompt employers to more quickly embrace automation. In other words, there’s a risk that militancy today can destroy union jobs tomorrow.

Oh, yes – how did I inadvertently help the ITU’s demise?

After newspapers computerized their news operations, typographers were still needed to create display ads. I joined a small high-tech company that built some of the first software and hardware that automated creating display ads. Our systems cost millions of dollars but were eagerly purchased by large newspapers.

The irony was that shortly after my company helped put the final nail in the ITU’s coffin, a new wave of computer companies such as Apple, Adobe and Hewlett-Packard created the desktop publishing revolution. That technological change put the company I worked for out of business.

Tags: Jay ZagorskyLabormedia mention
Jay Zagorsky

Jay Zagorsky

Jay Zagorsky is Clinical Associate Professor in Markets, Public Policy, & Law and is a cross-disciplinary researcher who has spent over two decades of researching a wide variety of personal wealth topics. He tries to explain why some people become rich, others are poor and some move between these two states. He is currently synthesizing this research into a book that presents the results of his academic research and other wealth researchers in an accessible format.

Related Insights

Boston dockworkers among thousands on strike nationwide 
Business Challenges

High tariffs, immigration crackdown, funding cuts: BU professor warns of ‘Trump Trifecta’ 

May 23, 2025
Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Rep. Madeleine Dean demand food and beverage CEOs put a stop to ‘shrinkflation’ 
Business Challenges

Mass. leaders worried for seniors and kids as Trump agenda bill clears House 

May 23, 2025
What Is ‘Big Law?’ 
Business Policy & Markets

Stop Making Cents: US Mint Moves Forward With Plans to Kill the Penny 

May 22, 2025
How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 
Future of Work

How to Attract (and Keep!) the Best Gen Z Employees 

May 21, 2025
How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”
Business Challenges

Could the GPT Store Turn ChatGPT into a Platform Powerhouse? 

May 21, 2025
The Right Amount of Cards, Cash and ID to Carry in Your Wallet
Business Functions

The ‘Best and Final’ Job Offer Usually Isn’t Final. How You Can Negotiate 

May 21, 2025

Upcoming Events

June 2025
Jun 07 2025

Mayor WU, BU Questrom Team Up to Host Civic Summit 2025

Boston University Questrom School of Business
No event found!

Get Our Insights Newsletter

Get Insights straight to your inbox by signing up now.

    Popular Insights

    • I’m a business professor who asked dozens of former students how they define success. Here are their lessons for today’s grads

      I’m a business professor who asked dozens of former students how they define success. Here are their lessons for today’s grads

      10 shares
      Share 4 Tweet 3
    • Massachusetts Economy at Risk from Trump Administration Policies  

      18 shares
      Share 7 Tweet 5
    • Poets&Quants Names Two Questrom Students 2025 Best & Brightest MBAs

      7 shares
      Share 3 Tweet 2
    • Why did Hertz just announce it was selling EVs and recording a massive loss? 

      67 shares
      Share 27 Tweet 17
    • How much profit do fireworks stands make?

      307 shares
      Share 123 Tweet 77

    Boston University Questrom School of Business
    595 Commonwealth Avenue
    Boston, MA 02215

    Follow Us

    Newsletter

    © 2023 Trustees of Boston University

    • About Us
    • Digital Business Institute
    • Human Resource Policy Institute
    • Susilo Institute for Ethics in the Global Economy

    Welcome Back!

    Sign In with Linked In
    OR

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In

    Add New Playlist

    Generic selectors
    Exact matches only
    Search in title
    Search in content
    Post Type Selectors
    Search in posts
    Search in Author
    Search Events
    Filter by Categories
    Action Learning
    Artificial Intelligence in Business
    Book Club
    Books
    BU Today
    Business Challenges
    Business Education
    Business Functions
    Business Policy & Markets
    Corporate Strategy
    Digital Business
    Digital Business Institute
    Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
    Entrepreneurship & Innovation
    Events
    Expert Take
    Feature
    Finance & Accounting
    Future of Business Education
    Future of Work
    Global Media
    Harvard Business Review
    Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech
    Human Resources Policy Institute
    Innovation
    Insights Live
    Institute for Sustainable Energy
    Journals
    Language of Business
    Leadership & Management
    Local Media
    Marketing
    Media Mention
    Multimedia
    National Media
    Newsletter Spotlight
    Op-Ed
    Operations
    Opinion
    Our Insights
    Partners in Business Ethics
    Podcast
    Publications
    Research Institutes
    Risk
    ScienceDirect
    Silicon Valley Bank
    Sloan Management Review
    Social Impact
    Special Series
    Susilo Institute for Ethics in the Global Economy
    Technology
    The Brink
    Thinkers50@BUQuestrom: Passion & Purpose
    Videos
    • Business Challenges
      • Business Policy & Markets
      • Digital Business
      • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
      • Entrepreneurship & Innovation
      • Future of Work
      • Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech
      • Risk
      • Social Impact
    • Business Functions
      • Corporate Strategy
      • Finance & Accounting
      • Innovation
      • Leadership & Management
      • Marketing
      • Operations
      • Technology
    • Publications
      • Journals
      • Harvard Business Review
      • Sloan Management Review
    • Insights Events
      • All Events
      • Insights Live
      • Questrom Institute Events
    • Videos & Podcast
      • Videos
      • Insights@Questrom Podcast
      • Podcast
    • Voices in the Media
    • Our Experts

    © 2023 Trustees of Boston University

    -
    00:00
    00:00

    Queue

    Update Required Flash plugin
    -
    00:00
    00:00