• About Us
  • Get Insights to Your Inbox
Saturday, May 10, 2025
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in Author
Search Events
Filter by Categories
Action Learning
Artificial Intelligence in Business
Book Club
Books
BU Today
Business Challenges
Business Education
Business Functions
Business Policy & Markets
Corporate Strategy
Digital Business
Digital Business Institute
Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
Entrepreneurship & Innovation
Events
Expert Take
Feature
Finance & Accounting
Future of Business Education
Future of Work
Global Media
Harvard Business Review
Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech
Human Resources Policy Institute
Innovation
Insights Live
Institute for Sustainable Energy
Journals
Language of Business
Leadership & Management
Local Media
Marketing
Media Mention
Multimedia
National Media
Newsletter Spotlight
Op-Ed
Operations
Opinion
Our Insights
Partners in Business Ethics
Podcast
Publications
Research Institutes
Risk
ScienceDirect
Silicon Valley Bank
Sloan Management Review
Social Impact
Special Series
Susilo Institute for Ethics in the Global Economy
Technology
The Brink
Thinkers50@BUQuestrom: Passion & Purpose
Videos
Insights@Questrom
  • Our Insights
    • All
    • Business Challenges
    • Business Education
    • Business Functions
    Massachusetts Economy at Risk from Trump Administration Policies  

    Massachusetts Economy at Risk from Trump Administration Policies  

    Small businesses may take the brunt of tariffs, even when they’re based in the US 

    Retail’s latest tariff challenge? Setting prices. 

    Bureaucrats get a bad rap, but they deserve more credit − a sociologist of work explains why

    Bureaucrats get a bad rap, but they deserve more credit − a sociologist of work explains why

    Gordon Burtch Named Finalist for the 2025 Bradford-Osborne Research Award

    Gordon Burtch Named Finalist for the 2025 Bradford-Osborne Research Award

    Best Personal Loans for a 600 Credit Score

    Why have car insurance premiums been increasing over the past years? 

    Trump looking at cutting US drug prices to international levels, sources say 

    Trump looking at cutting US drug prices to international levels, sources say 

    Small businesses in the US may take the brunt of tariffs 

    Small businesses in the US may take the brunt of tariffs 

    Executive Insights: Ned Rimer, Faculty Director, Health Sector Management Program, Questrom School of Business, Boston University (video)

    Tariffs are expected to worsen the divide between Main Street and Wall Street 

  • Videos & Podcast
    • All
    • Podcast
    • Videos
    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Tariffs and Their Economic Impact

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Navigating Internet Privacy: Unpacking Cookies, Dark Patterns, and Future Data Protection Challenges (2)

    Beyond Prototypes: Rethinking Innovation in Complex Ecosystems with Prof. Douglas Hannah

    Beyond Prototypes: Rethinking Innovation in Complex Ecosystems with Prof. Douglas Hannah

    Is Business Broken? Season 2 out now! 

    Is Business Broken? Season 2 out now! 

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Redefining Retirement: Navigating Emotional and Social Transitions with Insightful Strategies

    Life After Cookies: Who Uses Google’s Privacy Sandbox? – Garrett Johnson

    Life After Cookies: Who Uses Google’s Privacy Sandbox? – Garrett Johnson

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Real Estate Ripples from a Landmark Settlement

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    The Hidden Wisdom of Cultural Pushback

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Fusion Strategy: Navigating the Industrial Evolution

  • Insights Events
    • Events
    • Insights Live
    • Questrom Institute Events
  • In the Media
    • All
    • BU Today
    • Global Media
    • Local Media
    • National Media
    • Op-Ed
    • The Brink
    Small businesses may take the brunt of tariffs, even when they’re based in the US 

    Retail’s latest tariff challenge? Setting prices. 

    Best Personal Loans for a 600 Credit Score

    Why have car insurance premiums been increasing over the past years? 

    Trump looking at cutting US drug prices to international levels, sources say 

    Trump looking at cutting US drug prices to international levels, sources say 

    Small businesses in the US may take the brunt of tariffs 

    Small businesses in the US may take the brunt of tariffs 

    Executive Insights: Ned Rimer, Faculty Director, Health Sector Management Program, Questrom School of Business, Boston University (video)

    Tariffs are expected to worsen the divide between Main Street and Wall Street 

    How AI Chat Search Could Disrupt Online Advertising

    Boeing aircraft, duty-free no more 

    How AI Chat Search Could Disrupt Online Advertising

    Compounding pharmacies must stop making versions of Ozempic and Wegovy as shortage ends 

    In a ‘work-from-anywhere’ world, where are people working?

    Rising drug prices are hammering patients, employers, and insurers. Is there any end in sight? 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    How to Monetize Volunteer-Driven Platforms 

  • Publications
    • All
    • Books
    • Harvard Business Review
    • Journals
    • Sloan Management Review
    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    How to Monetize Volunteer-Driven Platforms 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Leading Global Teams Effectively 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Research: When Prototypes Don’t Yield Useful Insights 

    Transforming Products into Platforms: Unearthing New Avenues for Business Innovation

    Transforming Products into Platforms: Unearthing New Avenues for Business Innovation

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    We’re Still Lonely at Work

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    17 Team-Building Activities for In-Person, Remote, and Hybrid Teams

    3 Ways to Support Employees with Bipolar Disorder

    3 Ways to Support Employees with Bipolar Disorder

    Will That Marketplace Succeed?

    Will That Marketplace Succeed?

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Research: Why Companies Should Disclose Their Lack of Progress on DEI 

  • Questrom Book Club
Insights@Questrom
  • Our Insights
    • All
    • Business Challenges
    • Business Education
    • Business Functions
    Massachusetts Economy at Risk from Trump Administration Policies  

    Massachusetts Economy at Risk from Trump Administration Policies  

    Small businesses may take the brunt of tariffs, even when they’re based in the US 

    Retail’s latest tariff challenge? Setting prices. 

    Bureaucrats get a bad rap, but they deserve more credit − a sociologist of work explains why

    Bureaucrats get a bad rap, but they deserve more credit − a sociologist of work explains why

    Gordon Burtch Named Finalist for the 2025 Bradford-Osborne Research Award

    Gordon Burtch Named Finalist for the 2025 Bradford-Osborne Research Award

    Best Personal Loans for a 600 Credit Score

    Why have car insurance premiums been increasing over the past years? 

    Trump looking at cutting US drug prices to international levels, sources say 

    Trump looking at cutting US drug prices to international levels, sources say 

    Small businesses in the US may take the brunt of tariffs 

    Small businesses in the US may take the brunt of tariffs 

    Executive Insights: Ned Rimer, Faculty Director, Health Sector Management Program, Questrom School of Business, Boston University (video)

    Tariffs are expected to worsen the divide between Main Street and Wall Street 

  • Videos & Podcast
    • All
    • Podcast
    • Videos
    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Tariffs and Their Economic Impact

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Navigating Internet Privacy: Unpacking Cookies, Dark Patterns, and Future Data Protection Challenges (2)

    Beyond Prototypes: Rethinking Innovation in Complex Ecosystems with Prof. Douglas Hannah

    Beyond Prototypes: Rethinking Innovation in Complex Ecosystems with Prof. Douglas Hannah

    Is Business Broken? Season 2 out now! 

    Is Business Broken? Season 2 out now! 

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Redefining Retirement: Navigating Emotional and Social Transitions with Insightful Strategies

    Life After Cookies: Who Uses Google’s Privacy Sandbox? – Garrett Johnson

    Life After Cookies: Who Uses Google’s Privacy Sandbox? – Garrett Johnson

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Real Estate Ripples from a Landmark Settlement

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    The Hidden Wisdom of Cultural Pushback

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Fusion Strategy: Navigating the Industrial Evolution

  • Insights Events
    • Events
    • Insights Live
    • Questrom Institute Events
  • In the Media
    • All
    • BU Today
    • Global Media
    • Local Media
    • National Media
    • Op-Ed
    • The Brink
    Small businesses may take the brunt of tariffs, even when they’re based in the US 

    Retail’s latest tariff challenge? Setting prices. 

    Best Personal Loans for a 600 Credit Score

    Why have car insurance premiums been increasing over the past years? 

    Trump looking at cutting US drug prices to international levels, sources say 

    Trump looking at cutting US drug prices to international levels, sources say 

    Small businesses in the US may take the brunt of tariffs 

    Small businesses in the US may take the brunt of tariffs 

    Executive Insights: Ned Rimer, Faculty Director, Health Sector Management Program, Questrom School of Business, Boston University (video)

    Tariffs are expected to worsen the divide between Main Street and Wall Street 

    How AI Chat Search Could Disrupt Online Advertising

    Boeing aircraft, duty-free no more 

    How AI Chat Search Could Disrupt Online Advertising

    Compounding pharmacies must stop making versions of Ozempic and Wegovy as shortage ends 

    In a ‘work-from-anywhere’ world, where are people working?

    Rising drug prices are hammering patients, employers, and insurers. Is there any end in sight? 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    How to Monetize Volunteer-Driven Platforms 

  • Publications
    • All
    • Books
    • Harvard Business Review
    • Journals
    • Sloan Management Review
    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    How to Monetize Volunteer-Driven Platforms 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Leading Global Teams Effectively 

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Research: When Prototypes Don’t Yield Useful Insights 

    Transforming Products into Platforms: Unearthing New Avenues for Business Innovation

    Transforming Products into Platforms: Unearthing New Avenues for Business Innovation

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    We’re Still Lonely at Work

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    17 Team-Building Activities for In-Person, Remote, and Hybrid Teams

    3 Ways to Support Employees with Bipolar Disorder

    3 Ways to Support Employees with Bipolar Disorder

    Will That Marketplace Succeed?

    Will That Marketplace Succeed?

    How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

    Research: Why Companies Should Disclose Their Lack of Progress on DEI 

  • Questrom Book Club
Insights@Questrom
Home Our Insights Business Challenges Business Policy & Markets

The Wisdom of the Crowd and Prediction Markets

Steven KoubySteven Kou
January 11, 2022
in Business Policy & Markets, Finance & Accounting
171
0
The Wisdom of the Crowd and Prediction Markets

Large collection of people grouped together to form a brain icon

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

One of the most counter-intuitive but observable social phenomena is that a large enough group of people can make startlingly accurate predictions despite an individual lack of expertise, providing their guesses are made independently and then averaged together. This concept, which has come to be known as the “wisdom of the crowd,” can be more formally described as the gathering of information and making a prediction from a group’s aggregated inputs, even if the individual inputs are noisy. It was first was suggested by Galton (1907), who described a 1906 country fair in Plymouth in which the median guess of (about 800) people, participating in a contest to estimate the weight of an ox, was 1207 pounds, accurate within 1% of the true weight of 1198 pounds. In the era of digital innovation, this concept has been widely used by social information sites, like Wikipedia and Stack Exchange. See also a New York Times Business Bestseller, The Wisdom of Crowds: Why the Many are Smarter Than the Few and How Collective Wisdom Shapes Business, Economies, Societies, and Nations by James Surowiecki (2004).   

Although in many cases the idiosyncratic noise associated with each individual judgment gets cancelled over the average, leading to a good answer from either polls or prediction markets, in general there is no guarantee that the crowd wisdom yields a better judgment than an individual does. This is especially true if the majority of the people do not know the right answer (e.g. most of people might not realize that Philadelphia is not the capital of Pennsylvania) or the answer to a question is currently unknown to human beings (e.g. whether extraterrestrial life exists).

Surprisingly, a very creative solution is given in Prelec et al. (2017). They point out that in a survey if, in addition to answering one survey question, a participant is also asked to make a prediction of the distribution of answers to the survey question of the whole participants, then a consistent estimator related to a quantity in the objective world can be obtained, under a suitable set of regularity conditions on the subjective and objective worlds, if the majority of the people do not know the right answer. For example, if a survey question asks participants whether Philadelphia is the capital of Pennsylvania, then the simple majority vote obtained from the answers to the question may be wrong, as most of the participants may give the wrong answer. However, if, in addition to the original question, another question is asked about the respondent’s guess of the percentage of the respondents who correctly answer the first question, then a consistent estimator can be found by combining the answers to both questions, and by giving more weights to the answers by the minority respondents, who answer the first question correctly but think that the majority respondents will get the first question wrong.

Dai et al. (2021) study a related problem of the wisdom of the crowd, namely making predictions or judgments using prediction markets. In particular, they attempt to answer the following question: Can one design a prediction market, such that a consistent estimator can be found using data in this market? The answer is yes, if additional individual level data is available. Indeed, they give two estimators, a market-adjusted estimator based solely on market inputs including individual trading positions and a hybrid estimator based on both market and inputs from one survey question (instead of two questions), such that both estimators are consistent under the BTS setting, but under different regularity conditions. Furthermore, using a real data set of sports betting, which include trading positions of three groups (people betting on the home team, people betting on the away team and the bookmakers), Dai et al. (2021) find empirically that the market-adjusted estimator can significantly improve the accuracy of prediction, if the number of participants is large so that the market has enough liquidity.

References

Dai, M., Jia, Y., & Kou, S. (2021a). The wisdom of the crowd and prediction markets. Journal of Econometrics, 222, 561–578.

Galton, F. (1907). Vox populi. Nature, 75, 450–451.

Prelec, D., Seung, H. S., & McCoy, J. (2017). A solution to the single-question crowd wisdom problem. Nature, 541, 532–535.

Surowiecki, J. (2004). The Wisdom of Crowds: Why the Many Are Smarter Than the Few and How Collective Wisdom Shapes Business, Economies, Societies and Nations. Anchor Books, New York.

Tags: Prediction MarketsSteven Kou
Steven Kou

Steven Kou

Steven Kou is Questrom Professor of Management in Finance at Boston University Questrom School of Business.

Related Insights

13 Boston University Questrom School of Business Faculty Recognized As Top-Cited Scientists for Career-Long Impact 
Business Education

13 Boston University Questrom School of Business Faculty Recognized As Top-Cited Scientists for Career-Long Impact 

March 24, 2025
Why are Banks Failing and Does That Herald Another Financial Crisis?
BU Today

Beyond Bitcoin: Why Interest in Blockchain is Surging at BU

October 25, 2022
What Do We Know About Robo-Advising?
Digital Business

What Do We Know About Robo-Advising?

April 7, 2021

Upcoming Events

June 2025
Jun 07 2025

Mayor WU, BU Questrom Team Up to Host Civic Summit 2025

Boston University Questrom School of Business
No event found!

Get Our Insights Newsletter

Get Insights straight to your inbox by signing up now.

    Popular Insights

    • Massachusetts Economy at Risk from Trump Administration Policies  

      Massachusetts Economy at Risk from Trump Administration Policies  

      16 shares
      Share 6 Tweet 4
    • Ethical Implications of ChatGPT in the Educational Setting

      211 shares
      Share 84 Tweet 53
    • 2025 Digital Marketing Symposium: Sponsored by the Digital Business Institute

      8 shares
      Share 3 Tweet 2
    • Compounding pharmacies must stop making versions of Ozempic and Wegovy as shortage ends 

      8 shares
      Share 3 Tweet 2
    • 2025 Wadsworth Family Distinguished Lecture in Business Leadership & Technology Innovation – Peter Levine 

      8 shares
      Share 3 Tweet 2

    Boston University Questrom School of Business
    595 Commonwealth Avenue
    Boston, MA 02215

    Follow Us

    Newsletter

    © 2023 Trustees of Boston University

    • About Us
    • Digital Business Institute
    • Human Resource Policy Institute
    • Susilo Institute for Ethics in the Global Economy

    Welcome Back!

    Sign In with Linked In
    OR

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In

    Add New Playlist

    Generic selectors
    Exact matches only
    Search in title
    Search in content
    Post Type Selectors
    Search in posts
    Search in Author
    Search Events
    Filter by Categories
    Action Learning
    Artificial Intelligence in Business
    Book Club
    Books
    BU Today
    Business Challenges
    Business Education
    Business Functions
    Business Policy & Markets
    Corporate Strategy
    Digital Business
    Digital Business Institute
    Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
    Entrepreneurship & Innovation
    Events
    Expert Take
    Feature
    Finance & Accounting
    Future of Business Education
    Future of Work
    Global Media
    Harvard Business Review
    Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech
    Human Resources Policy Institute
    Innovation
    Insights Live
    Institute for Sustainable Energy
    Journals
    Language of Business
    Leadership & Management
    Local Media
    Marketing
    Media Mention
    Multimedia
    National Media
    Newsletter Spotlight
    Op-Ed
    Operations
    Opinion
    Our Insights
    Partners in Business Ethics
    Podcast
    Publications
    Research Institutes
    Risk
    ScienceDirect
    Silicon Valley Bank
    Sloan Management Review
    Social Impact
    Special Series
    Susilo Institute for Ethics in the Global Economy
    Technology
    The Brink
    Thinkers50@BUQuestrom: Passion & Purpose
    Videos
    • Business Challenges
      • Business Policy & Markets
      • Digital Business
      • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
      • Entrepreneurship & Innovation
      • Future of Work
      • Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech
      • Risk
      • Social Impact
    • Business Functions
      • Corporate Strategy
      • Finance & Accounting
      • Innovation
      • Leadership & Management
      • Marketing
      • Operations
      • Technology
    • Publications
      • Journals
      • Harvard Business Review
      • Sloan Management Review
    • Insights Events
      • All Events
      • Insights Live
      • Questrom Institute Events
    • Videos & Podcast
      • Videos
      • Insights@Questrom Podcast
      • Podcast
    • Voices in the Media
    • Our Experts

    © 2023 Trustees of Boston University

    -
    00:00
    00:00

    Queue

    Update Required Flash plugin
    -
    00:00
    00:00