• About Us
  • Get Insights to Your Inbox
Sunday, September 24, 2023
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Insights@Questrom
  • Our Insights
    • All
    • Business Challenges
    • Business Education
    • Business Functions
    Coworking Spaces Can Help Prevent Employee Loneliness, Isolation

    Coworking Spaces Can Help Prevent Employee Loneliness, Isolation

    Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging Station Installation on Foot-Traffic at Brick-and-Mortar Retailers

    Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging Station Installation on Foot-Traffic at Brick-and-Mortar Retailers

    How Apple Defines Consumer Logic

    How Apple Defines Consumer Logic

    There’s a Problem With the Telehealth Revolution 

    There’s a Problem With the Telehealth Revolution 

    We’re Not Racing to the Moon, We’re Making It Home 

    We’re Not Racing to the Moon, We’re Making It Home 

    What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

    What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

    The Hidden Risk of Getting Paid in Stock Options 

    How to Make American Health Care Cheaper and Better 

    What happens after the collapse of a 99-year-old trucking company?

    Millions of workers could soon receive a pay boost through new overtime rules 

  • Videos & Podcast
    • All
    • Podcast
    • Videos
    Shein & Forever 21 Strike a Deal

    Shein & Forever 21 Strike a Deal

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Questrom and BU Means Innovation and Entreprenuership

    A new travel nightmare: New passport delays lasting 13 weeks

    A new travel nightmare: New passport delays lasting 13 weeks

    Leadership Communications

    Leadership Communications

    Demotivating Effects of Relative Performance Feedback on Middle-Ranked Workers’ Performance

    Demotivating Effects of Relative Performance Feedback on Middle-Ranked Workers’ Performance

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    AI: What is it and how will it impact business?

    Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

    Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

    How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

    How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

    How Companies Deal with Disruption

    How Companies Deal with Disruption

  • Insights Events
    • Events
    • Insights Live
    • Questrom Institute Events
  • In the Media
    • All
    • BU Today
    • Global Media
    • Local Media
    • National Media
    • Op-Ed
    • The Brink
    Humira Competitors Don’t Guarantee Lower Patient Drug Costs

    Return to Office Brings CEO Relationships Back to the Forefront 

    Coworking Spaces Can Help Prevent Employee Loneliness, Isolation

    Coworking Spaces Can Help Prevent Employee Loneliness, Isolation

    How Apple Defines Consumer Logic

    How Apple Defines Consumer Logic

    There’s a Problem With the Telehealth Revolution 

    There’s a Problem With the Telehealth Revolution 

    Best Personal Loans for a 600 Credit Score

    Best Savings Accounts 

    We’re Not Racing to the Moon, We’re Making It Home 

    We’re Not Racing to the Moon, We’re Making It Home 

    What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

    What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

    The Hidden Risk of Getting Paid in Stock Options 

    How to Make American Health Care Cheaper and Better 

    What happens after the collapse of a 99-year-old trucking company?

    Millions of workers could soon receive a pay boost through new overtime rules 

    Trending Tags

    • Publications
      • All
      • Books
      • Harvard Business Review
      • Journals
      • Sloan Management Review
      AI Adoption in U.S. Health Care Won’t Be Easy 

      AI Adoption in U.S. Health Care Won’t Be Easy 

      Where Should Your Company Start with GenAI? 

      Where Should Your Company Start with GenAI? 

      How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

      How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

      Should Companies Refrain From Making Political Statements?

      Should Companies Refrain From Making Political Statements?

      Make It Safe for Employees to Speak Up – Especially in Risky Times

      Make It Safe for Employees to Speak Up – Especially in Risky Times

      Will Generative AI Create a New Era of Search Competition?

      Will Generative AI Create a New Era of Search Competition?

      A Better Approach to Customer-Centric Messaging and Engagement

      A Better Approach to Customer-Centric Messaging and Engagement

      How Coworking Spaces Impact Employee Well-Being

      How Coworking Spaces Impact Employee Well-Being

      Will Salary Transparency Laws Change Employee Compensation?

      Will Salary Transparency Laws Change Employee Compensation?

      Trending Tags

      Insights@Questrom
      • Our Insights
        • All
        • Business Challenges
        • Business Education
        • Business Functions
        Coworking Spaces Can Help Prevent Employee Loneliness, Isolation

        Coworking Spaces Can Help Prevent Employee Loneliness, Isolation

        Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging Station Installation on Foot-Traffic at Brick-and-Mortar Retailers

        Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging Station Installation on Foot-Traffic at Brick-and-Mortar Retailers

        How Apple Defines Consumer Logic

        How Apple Defines Consumer Logic

        There’s a Problem With the Telehealth Revolution 

        There’s a Problem With the Telehealth Revolution 

        We’re Not Racing to the Moon, We’re Making It Home 

        We’re Not Racing to the Moon, We’re Making It Home 

        What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

        What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

        The Hidden Risk of Getting Paid in Stock Options 

        How to Make American Health Care Cheaper and Better 

        What happens after the collapse of a 99-year-old trucking company?

        Millions of workers could soon receive a pay boost through new overtime rules 

      • Videos & Podcast
        • All
        • Podcast
        • Videos
        Shein & Forever 21 Strike a Deal

        Shein & Forever 21 Strike a Deal

        S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

        Questrom and BU Means Innovation and Entreprenuership

        A new travel nightmare: New passport delays lasting 13 weeks

        A new travel nightmare: New passport delays lasting 13 weeks

        Leadership Communications

        Leadership Communications

        Demotivating Effects of Relative Performance Feedback on Middle-Ranked Workers’ Performance

        Demotivating Effects of Relative Performance Feedback on Middle-Ranked Workers’ Performance

        S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

        AI: What is it and how will it impact business?

        Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

        Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

        How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

        How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

        How Companies Deal with Disruption

        How Companies Deal with Disruption

      • Insights Events
        • Events
        • Insights Live
        • Questrom Institute Events
      • In the Media
        • All
        • BU Today
        • Global Media
        • Local Media
        • National Media
        • Op-Ed
        • The Brink
        Humira Competitors Don’t Guarantee Lower Patient Drug Costs

        Return to Office Brings CEO Relationships Back to the Forefront 

        Coworking Spaces Can Help Prevent Employee Loneliness, Isolation

        Coworking Spaces Can Help Prevent Employee Loneliness, Isolation

        How Apple Defines Consumer Logic

        How Apple Defines Consumer Logic

        There’s a Problem With the Telehealth Revolution 

        There’s a Problem With the Telehealth Revolution 

        Best Personal Loans for a 600 Credit Score

        Best Savings Accounts 

        We’re Not Racing to the Moon, We’re Making It Home 

        We’re Not Racing to the Moon, We’re Making It Home 

        What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

        What Is ‘Big Law?’ 

        The Hidden Risk of Getting Paid in Stock Options 

        How to Make American Health Care Cheaper and Better 

        What happens after the collapse of a 99-year-old trucking company?

        Millions of workers could soon receive a pay boost through new overtime rules 

        Trending Tags

        • Publications
          • All
          • Books
          • Harvard Business Review
          • Journals
          • Sloan Management Review
          AI Adoption in U.S. Health Care Won’t Be Easy 

          AI Adoption in U.S. Health Care Won’t Be Easy 

          Where Should Your Company Start with GenAI? 

          Where Should Your Company Start with GenAI? 

          How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

          How Retailers Can Capitalize on the “Refund Effect”

          Should Companies Refrain From Making Political Statements?

          Should Companies Refrain From Making Political Statements?

          Make It Safe for Employees to Speak Up – Especially in Risky Times

          Make It Safe for Employees to Speak Up – Especially in Risky Times

          Will Generative AI Create a New Era of Search Competition?

          Will Generative AI Create a New Era of Search Competition?

          A Better Approach to Customer-Centric Messaging and Engagement

          A Better Approach to Customer-Centric Messaging and Engagement

          How Coworking Spaces Impact Employee Well-Being

          How Coworking Spaces Impact Employee Well-Being

          Will Salary Transparency Laws Change Employee Compensation?

          Will Salary Transparency Laws Change Employee Compensation?

          Trending Tags

          Insights@Questrom
          Home Our Insights Business Functions

          From Supply Chains to Climate Action: Exploring Scope 3 Emissions and Their Significance

          Estelle Yuan SunbyEstelle Yuan Sun
          June 26, 2023
          in Business Functions, Finance & Accounting
          19
          0
          From Supply Chains to Climate Action: Exploring Scope 3 Emissions and Their Significance
          Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

          What are scope 3 emissions?

          There are three scopes of greenhouse gas emissions: 

          • Scope 1 emissions are the direct emissions a company generates from sources under its ownership or control.  For an automobile manufacturer, scope 1 emissions come from the manufacturing process itself, such as emissions from paint booths or assembly lines.
          • Scope 2 emissions are indirect emissions arising from the energy purchased and consumed by a company. In the case of an automobile manufacturer, scope 2 emissions refer to the electricity used in the manufacturing process.
          • Scope 3 emissions cover a wider range and result from activities across a company’s value chain, including upstream and downstream activities. For example, for an automobile manufacturer, scope 3 includes emissions from customers driving vehicles after purchase (downstream) and emissions from suppliers of paints, adhesives, plastics, and other materials used by the automobile manufacturer (upstream).

          It’s important to note that scope 3 emissions have two unique characteristics. First, they constitute a significant portion of a company’s emissions, often representing around 75% of greenhouse gas emissions according to the CDP. In industries like financial services, scope 3 emissions can approach 100%. Secondly, as they encompass a company’s entire value chain, scope 3 emissions from one firm can be considered another firm’s scope 1 emissions. This emphasizes the interconnectedness and shared responsibility for reducing emissions across the supply chain.

          What do you see as the major reasons that regulators must address scope 3 emissions measurement in financial statements?

          Many countries, regions, and firms have set ambitious climate change mitigation goals, aiming to reduce carbon emissions and reach net-zero emissions within specific timelines. Given the sheer size of scope 3 emissions compared to scope 1 and 2 emissions for most industries, accurate reporting and active management of scope 3 emissions are crucial for firms to align their operations with these global goals.

          Investors now place greater importance on climate-related information for their investment decisions. They recognize that climate risks can pose significant financial implications for companies and therefore require reliable information on these risks. Regulators like the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) play a crucial role in hitting the high demand for consistent and comparable information. In its 2022 proposal to enhance and standardize climate-related disclosure, the SEC highlights the value of measuring and disclosing scope 3 emissions. Doing so could enable investors to better assess the full magnitude of climate-related risks associated with a company’s greenhouse gas emissions, support firms in achieving emission targets, facilitate comparisons between companies, and fill information gaps that could lead to incomplete or misleading impressions with disclosure limited to scopes 1 and 2 emissions. Furthermore, the SEC acknowledges that the disclosure of scope 3 emissions has already generated actual benefits, stating that “capital markets have begun to assign financial value to this type of metric, such that it can be material information for investors about financial risks facing an industry.”

          What challenges do managers face when measuring and managing scope 3 emissions?

          The Greenhouse Gas Protocol Corporate Value Chain Accounting and Reporting Standard helps firms assess their entire value chain emissions. The Standard creates a map of a firm’s entire upstream and downstream activities, including a life-cycle analysis of emissions associated with sold products and firm assets on and off the balance sheet. There are at least four critical issues while implementing this Standard.

          • First, the cost of mapping emissions of a full value chain map of emissions could be prohibitively high. S&P Global estimates first-time direct costs ranging from $245,000 to $355,000 per firm.
          • Second, a mapping exercise is likely to reveal sensitive proprietary information concerning both the firm and its suppliers, compromising the firm’s competitive advantages.
          • Third, scope 3 estimations are mostly done by outside organizations. Outsourcing to outside organizations may result in excessive imprecision, leading to compliance with the standard’s requirements only in form. For example, they may map only a fraction of the company’s supply chain, focusing on a few level 1 suppliers only.
          • Fourth, given the leeway for firms in the SEC proposal to use different methods for scope 3 emissions, there may also be little chance that the measures would be comparable across firms and, thus, create a benefit for investors.

          How can greater transparency and disclosure around scope 3 emissions help investors, customers, and other stakeholders understand a company’s environmental impact and make more informed decisions?

          It’s difficult to find public information on a firms’ scope 3 emissions. Without disclosures from companies, investors and other stakeholders cannot determine if firms are living up to their stated climate commitments or how exposed they are to changing policies aimed at reducing emissions.

          Specifically, the disclosure of scope 3 emissions provides investors with a more complete understanding of the firm’s environmental impact beyond its direct operations. This disclosure enables investors to evaluate the potential physical, regulatory, reputational, and financial risks associated with climate change. With access to this information, customers can evaluate the sustainability credentials of any product or service they consume, and consequently may avoid products from firms with higher emissions. Moreover, the disclosure will also allow customers to understand how much they contribute to the scope 3 emission and ways to reduce their own environmental footprint.

          Did your studies reveal any surprising details about scope 3 emissions for corporate reporting?

          In our article titled, “The Conundrum of Scope 3 Emissions for Corporate Reporting”, we highlight that, despite constituting for the largest number of emissions, scope 3 emissions have been overlooked by firms, regulators, and researchers. This is the conundrum.

          To gain insight into the extent of scope 3 emissions disclosed at the firm level, we examined the SEC filings of publicly traded U.S. firms between 2001 and 2022. We considered any mention of scope 3 related keywords as an indicator of disclosure, regardless of whether a firm quantified its scope 3 emissions. Although there was no specific requirement for such disclosure during the sample period, the SEC did call for the disclosure of material information on the impact and risks of climate change in annual reports as early as 2010. Some firms would have already disclosed certain scope 3 information based on the SEC’s materiality guidelines. Surprisingly, we found that the scope 3 emission disclosure in financial reports is sparse at best. However, there has been a notable increase in recent years (2020-2022), possibly driven by the anticipation of SEC’s 2022 proposal for climate-related disclosure, or increasing demands from investors, or regulations in other countries.

          Regulators are also just beginning to consider mandating their disclosure in financial reports. While the anticipated adoption of the SEC’s proposed standardized disclosure should potentially enhance transparency and consistency of information on firms’ emissions, it will undoubtedly impose significant costs on U.S. public companies.

          In light of concerns over costs, many companies have relied upon estimates of scope 3 emissions from external data providers instead of producing their own estimates. However, evidence suggests that these estimates lack reliability, completeness, and comparability. Moreover, data providers often do not describe the methods and models used to estimate scope 3 emissions. This lack of transparency makes it difficult to compare emission amounts across firms. Finally, potentially due to the above issues, research has shown very low correlations of scope 3 emissions among different data providers, casting doubt on the reliability of any single provider’s estimate for assessing firms’ emissions risk.

          Why have regulators been slow in mandating scope 3 emissions reporting and why are companies reluctant to report data?

          Regulators have been hesitant to mandate scope 3 emissions reporting. First, measuring and accurately allocating scope 3 emissions is complex, requiring data collection from multiple parties in a company’s value chain. This complexity is amplified for businesses with global supply chains. Regulators aim to enhance reporting consistency and comparability, but it remains uncertain whether mandating scope 3 emissions will achieve these goals, as different measurement models and levels can be employed.

          Second, regulators may be mindful of the potential impacts on businesses’ competitiveness if scope 3 emissions reporting become mandated. Requiring companies to disclose such information throughout the supply chain could expose them to scrutiny and comparison with industry peers. Concerns may arise regarding the potential for disclosing sensitive business information, proprietary data, or trade secret. Regulators need to strike a balance between transparency and protecting companies’ confidential information.

          Third, the collective research evidence has yet to document that financial markets will work better in the interests of society defined broadly –with mandatory environmental disclosure, including the efficient pricing of social and environmental externalities. Since measuring and reporting scope 3 emissions can be costly, it may lead to a number of potential litigations if companies perceive that the costs of mandatory disclosure over that of the present system which is essentially one of the constrained voluntary disclosure are greater than the benefits from a common set of disclosure rules (to increase consistency and comparability).

          Tags: disclosure in the workplaceenvironmental impactEstelle Yuan Sunfeaturedresearch
          Estelle Yuan Sun

          Estelle Yuan Sun

          Estelle completed her Ph.D. in Accounting and her MS in Business Administration at Haas School of Business, University of California at Berkeley. Prior to joining the Ph.D. program at Berkeley, she received a Bachelor of Commerce in Accounting with first-class honours at the University of Otago in New Zealand. Her research interests include corporate social responsibility, earnings management, investors’ use of financial information, accounting conservatism, disclosure, and analyst research.

          Related Insights

          Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging Station Installation on Foot-Traffic at Brick-and-Mortar Retailers
          Feature

          Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging Station Installation on Foot-Traffic at Brick-and-Mortar Retailers

          September 13, 2023
          Women Scientists: Is Bias Keeping Them from Success?
          Business Challenges

          Women Scientists: Is Bias Keeping Them from Success?

          August 2, 2023
          “Apologies for the confusion. I’ve made a mistake…”
          Artificial Intelligence in Business

          “Apologies for the confusion. I’ve made a mistake…”

          July 12, 2023
          Leadership Communications
          Business Education

          Leadership Communications

          April 27, 2023
          Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High
          Business Policy & Markets

          Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High

          February 23, 2023
          How Will AI & Machine Learning Impact Your Business?
          Digital Business

          Do People Believe Generative AI?

          February 2, 2023

          Upcoming Events

          October 2023
          Oct 10 2023

          Generative AI Perspectives

          Questrom Executive Dining Rooms
          Oct 25 2023

          M&A and Product Management in the Tech Industry

          Questrom Executive Dining Rooms
          November 2023
          Nov 08 2023

          The Unintended Consequences of Digital Health Innovation

          Questrom Executive Dining Rooms
          Nov 16 2023

          Digital Marketing Symposium

          Questrom Executive Dining Rooms
          No event found!

          Get Our Insights Newsletter

          Get Insights straight to your inbox by signing up now.

            Popular Insights

            • What Francesca Gino’s Harvard Lawsuit Says About Data Colada’s Fraud Allegations

              What Francesca Gino’s Harvard Lawsuit Says About Data Colada’s Fraud Allegations

              17 shares
              Share 7 Tweet 4
            • Ethical Implications of ChatGPT in the Educational Setting

              123 shares
              Share 49 Tweet 31
            • Silicon Valley Bank: Blame and Ethics of the Failure

              56 shares
              Share 22 Tweet 14
            • Stop Comparing ChatGPT to Calculators!

              34 shares
              Share 14 Tweet 9
            • [Marketplace] How much profit do fireworks stands make?

              121 shares
              Share 48 Tweet 30

            Boston University Questrom School of Business
            595 Commonwealth Avenue
            Boston, MA 02215

            Follow Us

            Newsletter

            © 2023 Trustees of Boston University

            • About Us
            • Digital Business Institute
            • Human Resource Policy Institute
            • Susilo Institute for Ethics in the Global Economy
            Generic selectors
            Exact matches only
            Search in title
            Search in content
            Post Type Selectors
            • Business Challenges
              • Business Policy & Markets
              • Digital Business
              • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
              • Entrepreneurship & Innovation
              • Future of Work
              • Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech
              • Risk
              • Social Impact
            • Business Functions
              • Corporate Strategy
              • Finance & Accounting
              • Innovation
              • Leadership & Management
              • Marketing
              • Operations
              • Technology
            • Publications
              • Journals
              • Harvard Business Review
              • Sloan Management Review
            • Insights Events
              • All Events
              • Insights Live
              • Questrom Institute Events
            • Videos & Podcast
              • Videos
              • Insights@Questrom Podcast
              • Podcast
            • Voices in the Media
            • Our Experts

            © 2023 Trustees of Boston University

            Welcome Back!

            Sign In with Linked In
            OR

            Login to your account below

            Forgotten Password?

            Retrieve your password

            Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

            Log In

            Warning: Undefined array key "fcb_field_mode" in /www/questrominsights_205/public/wp-content/plugins/floating-contact/floating-contact.php on line 184

            Add New Playlist

            -
            00:00
            00:00

            Queue

            Update Required Flash plugin
            -
            00:00
            00:00