• About Us
  • Get Insights to Your Inbox
Monday, March 27, 2023
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Insights@Questrom
  • Our Insights
    • All
    • Business Challenges
    • Business Education
    • Business Functions
    Starbucks fans are steamed:

    Starbucks fans are steamed:

    Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

    Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

    How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

    How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

    RxPass smartphone interface. (Amazon Photo)

    Meet Amazon’s New Prescription Plan: RxPass

    Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High

    Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High

    MBA Case Competitions: Meet Boston University’s Master Case Coach

    MBA Case Competitions: Meet Boston University’s Master Case Coach

    How Will AI & Machine Learning Impact Your Business?

    Do People Believe Generative AI?

    Buying gifts? Why ‘buy now, pay later’ could be a dangerous option for many holiday shoppers

    Buying gifts? Why ‘buy now, pay later’ could be a dangerous option for many holiday shoppers

  • Videos & Podcast
    • All
    • Podcast
    • Videos
    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    AI: What is it and how will impact business?

    Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

    Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

    How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

    How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

    How Companies Deal with Disruption

    How Companies Deal with Disruption

    Money: It’s created. It’s destroyed. But what is it?

    Money: It’s created. It’s destroyed. But what is it?

    Blockchain, Beyond Crypto

    Blockchain, Beyond Crypto

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    S1:E2 What the FTX?

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

    Gender Differences and the Job Search

    Gender Differences and the Job Search

  • Insights Events
    • Events
    • Insights Live
    • Questrom Institute Events
  • In the Media
    • All
    • BU Today
    • Global Media
    • Local Media
    • National Media
    • Op-Ed
    • The Brink
    Could This Meeting Have Been an Email?

    Could This Meeting Have Been an Email?

    Bankers Are Scoring Big Profits as Rates Soar. Now They’re Facing a Backlash

    Bankers Are Scoring Big Profits as Rates Soar. Now They’re Facing a Backlash

    A Risk Management Nightmare at Silicon Valley Bank

    A Risk Management Nightmare at Silicon Valley Bank

    SVB Crisis: What happened and what’s ahead?

    SVB Crisis: What happened and what’s ahead?

    Why are Banks Failing and Does That Herald Another Financial Crisis?

    Why are Banks Failing and Does That Herald Another Financial Crisis?

    Companies Scramble to Meet Payroll, Pay Bills After SVB’s Swift Failure

    Companies Scramble to Meet Payroll, Pay Bills After SVB’s Swift Failure

    Million-Dollar Teardowns

    Million-Dollar Teardowns

    Can We Trust ChatGPT and Artificial Intelligence to do Humans’ Work?

    Can We Trust ChatGPT and Artificial Intelligence to do Humans’ Work?

    [WalletHub] Expert Thoughts on Chase Freedom Unlimited

    Best Car Insurance Companies

    Trending Tags

    • Publications
      • All
      • Books
      • Harvard Business Review
      • Journals
      • Sloan Management Review
      Will Generative AI Create a New Era of Search Competition?

      Will Generative AI Create a New Era of Search Competition?

      ‘Your Messaging Sucks’

      ‘Your Messaging Sucks’

      How Coworking Spaces Impact Employee Well-Being

      How Coworking Spaces Impact Employee Well-Being

      Will Salary Transparency Laws Change Employee Compensation?

      Will Salary Transparency Laws Change Employee Compensation?

      Heroes from Above But Not (Always) from Within? Gig workers’ reactions to the sudden public moralization of their work

      Heroes from Above But Not (Always) from Within? Gig workers’ reactions to the sudden public moralization of their work

      To Encourage Patients to Fill Prescriptions, Fix Copays

      To Encourage Patients to Fill Prescriptions, Fix Copays

      Is Tesla’s Era of Dominance Coming to an End? What Experts Say

      Is Tesla’s Era of Dominance Coming to an End? What Experts Say

      ESG Investing

      ESG Investing Isn’t Designed to Save the Planet

      Epinephrine Autoinjector Costs Remain High for Some Patients with Private Insurance

      Epinephrine Autoinjector Costs Remain High for Some Patients with Private Insurance

      Trending Tags

      Insights@Questrom
      • Our Insights
        • All
        • Business Challenges
        • Business Education
        • Business Functions
        Starbucks fans are steamed:

        Starbucks fans are steamed:

        Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

        Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

        How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

        How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

        RxPass smartphone interface. (Amazon Photo)

        Meet Amazon’s New Prescription Plan: RxPass

        Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High

        Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High

        MBA Case Competitions: Meet Boston University’s Master Case Coach

        MBA Case Competitions: Meet Boston University’s Master Case Coach

        How Will AI & Machine Learning Impact Your Business?

        Do People Believe Generative AI?

        Buying gifts? Why ‘buy now, pay later’ could be a dangerous option for many holiday shoppers

        Buying gifts? Why ‘buy now, pay later’ could be a dangerous option for many holiday shoppers

      • Videos & Podcast
        • All
        • Podcast
        • Videos
        S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

        AI: What is it and how will impact business?

        Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

        Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

        How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

        How Higher Ed Can Contend with Learning Platforms

        How Companies Deal with Disruption

        How Companies Deal with Disruption

        Money: It’s created. It’s destroyed. But what is it?

        Money: It’s created. It’s destroyed. But what is it?

        Blockchain, Beyond Crypto

        Blockchain, Beyond Crypto

        S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

        S1:E2 What the FTX?

        S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

        S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry

        Gender Differences and the Job Search

        Gender Differences and the Job Search

      • Insights Events
        • Events
        • Insights Live
        • Questrom Institute Events
      • In the Media
        • All
        • BU Today
        • Global Media
        • Local Media
        • National Media
        • Op-Ed
        • The Brink
        Could This Meeting Have Been an Email?

        Could This Meeting Have Been an Email?

        Bankers Are Scoring Big Profits as Rates Soar. Now They’re Facing a Backlash

        Bankers Are Scoring Big Profits as Rates Soar. Now They’re Facing a Backlash

        A Risk Management Nightmare at Silicon Valley Bank

        A Risk Management Nightmare at Silicon Valley Bank

        SVB Crisis: What happened and what’s ahead?

        SVB Crisis: What happened and what’s ahead?

        Why are Banks Failing and Does That Herald Another Financial Crisis?

        Why are Banks Failing and Does That Herald Another Financial Crisis?

        Companies Scramble to Meet Payroll, Pay Bills After SVB’s Swift Failure

        Companies Scramble to Meet Payroll, Pay Bills After SVB’s Swift Failure

        Million-Dollar Teardowns

        Million-Dollar Teardowns

        Can We Trust ChatGPT and Artificial Intelligence to do Humans’ Work?

        Can We Trust ChatGPT and Artificial Intelligence to do Humans’ Work?

        [WalletHub] Expert Thoughts on Chase Freedom Unlimited

        Best Car Insurance Companies

        Trending Tags

        • Publications
          • All
          • Books
          • Harvard Business Review
          • Journals
          • Sloan Management Review
          Will Generative AI Create a New Era of Search Competition?

          Will Generative AI Create a New Era of Search Competition?

          ‘Your Messaging Sucks’

          ‘Your Messaging Sucks’

          How Coworking Spaces Impact Employee Well-Being

          How Coworking Spaces Impact Employee Well-Being

          Will Salary Transparency Laws Change Employee Compensation?

          Will Salary Transparency Laws Change Employee Compensation?

          Heroes from Above But Not (Always) from Within? Gig workers’ reactions to the sudden public moralization of their work

          Heroes from Above But Not (Always) from Within? Gig workers’ reactions to the sudden public moralization of their work

          To Encourage Patients to Fill Prescriptions, Fix Copays

          To Encourage Patients to Fill Prescriptions, Fix Copays

          Is Tesla’s Era of Dominance Coming to an End? What Experts Say

          Is Tesla’s Era of Dominance Coming to an End? What Experts Say

          ESG Investing

          ESG Investing Isn’t Designed to Save the Planet

          Epinephrine Autoinjector Costs Remain High for Some Patients with Private Insurance

          Epinephrine Autoinjector Costs Remain High for Some Patients with Private Insurance

          Trending Tags

          Insights@Questrom
          Home Our Insights Business Challenges

          Mirror, Mirror on the MA Ballot: Is Question 1 the Fairest Tax of Them All?

          Petro (Pete) LisowskybyPetro (Pete) Lisowsky
          October 20, 2022
          in Business Challenges, Feature
          15
          A A
          Mirror, Mirror on the MA Ballot: Is Question 1 the Fairest Tax of Them All?

          This proposed change, presented in Question 1 on the Massachusetts ballot, has generated significant debate on the pros and cons of a new tax on the wealthy.

          To learn more about Question 1, Questrom Insights discussed this proposal with Pete Lisowsky, Associate Professor of Accounting and Dean’s Research Scholar at the Questrom School of Business. Prof. Lisowsky has taught various tax courses at BU, MIT, and the University of Illinois, and worked at the U.S. Treasury and IRS in various research capacities for 15 years. He is currently the President of the American Taxation Association.

          What is the main goal of Question 1?

          Question 1 seeks to amend Article 44 of the Massachusetts Constitution to levy a new and higher tax on incomes over $1 million. The tax rate on this portion of income will be 4%. Currently Massachusetts levies a 5% tax on all income, so the combined tax rate on incomes over $1 million would become 9%.

          The language of the amendment states that the funds collected from the tax will be used for public education such as schools and universities, as well as infrastructure such as roads and bridges. The exact appropriations will be left to the legislature to decide.

          The $1 million threshold will be adjusted annually based on inflation, the same way the federal income tax system is adjusted annually for inflation.

          If passed, the new tax would go into effect on January 1, 2023.

          What are some key arguments that Proponents make in favor of Question 1?

          The key argument that proponents of Question 1 make is that top earners in Massachusetts do not pay their fair share of income taxes. This argument is based on the fact that Massachusetts imposes a flat 5% tax on all income earned by Massachusetts residents. As a result, top earners pay the same proportion of their income in taxes as low earners do. This structure is different from the federal income tax structure, which is based on progressive tax rates where greater amounts of income are taxed at higher rates. For example, the lowest U.S. federal income tax rate on salaries is 10% while the highest is 37%, with 5 tax rates in-between that rise as income rises. The proposed amendment would thus align the Massachusetts tax rate structure to the federal structure and ensure that higher income earners pay more of their income in taxes than lower income earners.

          Question 1 also proposes to use the new tax revenues to fund public education and physical infrastructure. These appropriations are subject to the legislative process, but as written, the amendment would likely prevent state lawmakers from using the funds for other purposes. Therefore, the added funding into public education will keep Massachusetts schools as the best in the nation.

          Proponents of Question 1 believe that the change will increase annual state revenues by $2 billion. However, the Massachusetts Executive Office of Administration and Finance estimates that figure to be closer to $1.2 billion; even so, this figure represents a significant 2.4% of the current annual state budget. The Office admits, however, that the amount of taxes will vary significantly year to year and may be unpredictable, as taxpayers may also decide to relocate their home or business to another, presumably lower-tax state.

          What are some key arguments that Opponents make against Question 1?

          The arguments that opponents to Question 1 make is that the tax would create a combined 9% marginal tax rate in Massachusetts, which in effect is an 80% tax increase over the current 5% level. By making the top marginal tax rate 9%, Massachusetts would move from a rather lower-tax state—more than half of U.S. states have tax rates higher than Massachusetts—to the #7 highest income tax state, after New York, Oregon, California, New Jersey, Hawaii, and Minnesota.

          Opponents also point out that there is no language in the amendment to ensure that certain types of income, such as those from selling a home, business, or farm, would be exempt from the 4% surtax. As a result, the surtax would bite into lifelong work to build wealth and leave less for retirement.

          Furthermore, there is no guarantee that the legislature will in fact add the new tax proceeds to their current appropriations on public education and infrastructure. The danger is that lawmakers will be tempted to use the new tax revenues to substitute for the current priorities, and thus free up cash to fund yet-to-be-determined priorities.

          Finally, the state currently has a surplus of over $5 billion and will be mailing $3 billion in refund checks to Massachusetts taxpayers. In addition, the state’s Stabilization Fund (i.e., rainy day fund) is almost $7 billion. The argument is that it makes no sense to increase taxes to simply add to huge surpluses that will just be returned. Instead, politicians should appropriate more of the funds that they already have for education and infrastructure, and that a new tax is not necessary in the current environment.

          How do you see Question 1 being decided?

          At the heart of it, Question 1 is asking Massachusetts voters to make a value judgment. On the one side, Proponents argue that the flat 5% tax rate is unfair to lower income earners, and higher income earners should pay significantly more—upwards to 80% more—than they currently do. This change is targeted at the Top 1% of taxpayers. By raising taxes on the wealthy and directing it towards schools and infrastructure, proponents argue that this amendment will build an economy that works for everyone and make our tax system fairer.

          On the other side is the argument that Massachusetts already has huge multi-billion-dollar surpluses. The state is so flush with tax revenues that a sleepy old law from 1986 was automatically triggered that requires the state to send refund checks to taxpayers for their prior taxes paid. The state seems to be bringing in money faster than it can handle appropriating. Interestingly, this automatic tax refund law, now known as Chapter 62F, was passed in 1986 using a similar statewide ballot question. But different from the current ballot question, Chapter 62F is a way to cap the growth of government revenues.

          I think the Proponents’ arguments, at least in the current budget environment, seem like an uphill fight. The state doesn’t appear to need more tax revenue from its citizens. If Proponents would like for lawmakers to fund more education and infrastructure projects, then it seems that a more suitable approach would be to educate the legislators on the benefits of appropriating more of the surplus and rainy day fund to meet these goals. In fact, with Maura Healey’s likely victory for Governor adding to an overwhelmingly Democratic legislature, to me these aims could very likely be accomplished absent the passage of Question 1.

          So between the state already being flush with cash and a legitimate legislative process under which the funds could still be deployed for education and infrastructure, it becomes a debate between values around income inequality and values of how much government should collect in taxes from its citizens as a whole. Namely, how much is enough?

          Is there a potential compromise to Question 1?

          A key challenge I see with Question 1 is one of marketing around the proposed progressive tax rate structure. I would have instead proposed to keep the 5% state tax rate on incomes over $1 million intact, but create a reduced tax rate, say 3% or 4%, for taxpayers with incomes less than $1 million. In effect, my “amendment to the amendment” could engineer both a progressive income tax rate structure in Massachusetts, under which high earners do pay proportionately more than low earners, but also give a permanent tax cut to these lower-income workers.

          By reducing the total state tax revenues collected from the lower income earners, this proposed structure would also prevent taxes from being refunded automatically under Chapter 62F. Interestingly, those refunds will still be going to the highest income earners, since on a nominal level, they have paid the most in taxes. Therefore, without changing Section 62F, Question 1 might not have much of a bite even if it is approved by voters and if budget surpluses continue. Section 62F might simply force the higher taxes to be returned.

          Overall, by lowering the tax rate on lower and middle-class earners, they will get a meaningful tax cut, while the wealthy will continue paying their tax bills, but at the relatively higher rate. And at the state level, Massachusetts would still be able to balance its books and fund its priorities. Providing current and sustained tax relief to working class families while keeping high earners equally productive in Massachusetts is a position that, I hope, can generate some common ground.

          I look forward to seeing the outcome of this ballot question and assess, regardless of the outcome, whether and how future tax policy might change in Massachusetts.

          Tags: Ballot QuestionfeaturedMA ElectionsPete LisowskyTaxes
          Share2Tweet1ShareShareSend
          Petro (Pete) Lisowsky

          Petro (Pete) Lisowsky

          Related Posts

          Starbucks fans are steamed:
          Business Policy & Markets

          Starbucks fans are steamed:

          March 14, 2023
          Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?
          Digital Business

          Is Creativity in Advertising Dead in the age of AI?

          March 8, 2023
          RxPass smartphone interface. (Amazon Photo)
          Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech

          Meet Amazon’s New Prescription Plan: RxPass

          February 26, 2023
          Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High
          Business Policy & Markets

          Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High

          February 23, 2023
          How Will AI & Machine Learning Impact Your Business?
          Digital Business

          Do People Believe Generative AI?

          February 2, 2023
          Buying gifts? Why ‘buy now, pay later’ could be a dangerous option for many holiday shoppers
          Business Policy & Markets

          Buying gifts? Why ‘buy now, pay later’ could be a dangerous option for many holiday shoppers

          December 19, 2022
          Larry Fink Asked to Step Down by Bluebell (London) – He Shouldn’t
          Feature

          Larry Fink Asked to Step Down by Bluebell (London) – He Shouldn’t

          December 15, 2022
          S1:E1 CVS Paying the “Pink Tax” on Certain Products and the Evolution of the Electric Vehicle Industry
          Podcast

          S1:E2 What the FTX?

          December 9, 2022

          Upcoming Events

          12 April 2023

          Insights@Questrom Live: A Conversation with Jerold Zimmerman

          Questrom Executive Dining Rooms, 595 Commonwealth Avenue, Fourth Floor, Boston, MA, 02215

          View Detail
          Check back soon for upcoming events

          Missed an Event? Click Here to Watch Previous Insights Live Events

          Get Our Insights Newsletter

          Get Insights straight to your inbox by signing up now.

            Popular Insights

            • Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High

              Inflation Cools, Prices Remain High

              21 shares
              Share 8 Tweet 5
            • Ethical Implications of ChatGPT in the Educational Setting

              18 shares
              Share 7 Tweet 5
            • Silicon Valley Bank: Blame and Ethics of the Failure

              11 shares
              Share 4 Tweet 3
            • How Serious is “Reverse Discrimination”?

              9 shares
              Share 4 Tweet 2
            • Would you buy a car from this man?

              8 shares
              Share 3 Tweet 2

            Boston University Questrom School of Business
            595 Commonwealth Avenue
            Boston, MA 02215

            Follow Us

            Newsletter

            © 2023 Trustees of Boston University

            • About Us
            • Digital Business Institute
            • Human Resource Policy Institute
            • Susilo Institute for Ethics in the Global Economy
            Generic selectors
            Exact matches only
            Search in title
            Search in content
            Post Type Selectors
            • Business Challenges
              • Business Policy & Markets
              • Digital Business
              • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
              • Entrepreneurship & Innovation
              • Future of Work
              • Health, Biopharma, & Health-Tech
              • Risk
              • Social Impact
            • Business Functions
              • Corporate Strategy
              • Finance & Accounting
              • Innovation
              • Leadership & Management
              • Marketing
              • Operations
              • Technology
            • Publications
              • Journals
              • Harvard Business Review
              • Sloan Management Review
            • Insights Events
              • All Events
              • Insights Live
              • Questrom Institute Events
            • Videos & Podcast
              • Videos
              • Insights@Questrom Podcast
              • Podcast
            • Voices in the Media
            • Our Experts

            © 2023 Trustees of Boston University

            Welcome Back!

            Sign In with Linked In
            OR

            Login to your account below

            Forgotten Password?

            Retrieve your password

            Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

            Log In
            Suggest Topic
            X

            Add New Playlist

            -
            00:00
            00:00

            Queue

            Update Required Flash plugin
            -
            00:00
            00:00